Film Reviews - Written by AdminHQ on Thursday, September 18, 2008 6:55 - 2 Comments

The Protector (1985)

The Protector

Director: James Glickenhaus

Starring: Jackie Chan, Danny Aiello, Roy Chiao, Bill ‘Superfoot’ Wallace,

Featuring: Kim Bass, Joe Wong, Sally Yeh

Written and directed by James Glickenhaus, The Protector was Jackie’s last attempt to gain entry to the US market until Rumble in the Bronx. With Battle Creek Brawl and appearances in the Cannonball Run series failing to set the States alight, Jackie went the way of the New York cop.

Jackie plays Billy Wong, a member of New York’s finest whose partner is killed during a hold-up. After taking out the murderer with no little property damage, Billy is busted to guard duty, and finds himself at a fashion launch party with officer Garoni (played by Aiello). The party is crashed by masked hoods who kidnap the hostess, the daughter of the biggest New York crime boss. After learning that she is being held in Honk Kong, Billy and Garoni get themselves sent there to rescue the girl, take out the crime lord responsible and in doing so bust up the biggest heroin route between China and America. Using guns and swearing.

Within seconds of Chan’s first scene, his dodgy accent is swiftly explained by his having arrived in the country ten years previously. Billy Wong is obviously not a fast learner. The South Bronx is set as one of those urban nightmares so popular with late 70s and early 80s American cinema – full of gangs wearing unrealistically complex outfits out of an Adam Ant promo. Think dwarf pirates. It’s not an 80s generic crime movie unless someone is thrown over a bar, but the Protector is eager to please. The Protector ticks a lot of the stereotype boxes of the police revenge genre, with lots of swearing, bloody shootouts, big explosions, a screaming police captain, and even obligatory nudity, in this case in a massage parlour rather than the genre favourite strip joint, although it gains points for achieving nudity by having all the women in the bad guy’s drug factory inexplicably work in the nude. Bizarre!

Whilst the crime picture side of things is thoroughly generic, it fares better with the Jackie Chan input, offering up some good stunts in the Hong Kong harbour and a handful of typically inventive fight scenes. However, the martial arts do take a back seat to the copious gunfights and slow-mo squib deaths. This wouldn’t necessarily be a problem if it made something of the gunplay, but there is nothing here to rival Tsui Hark or John Woo. Danny Aiello is good in a limited role, and the Hong Kong backdrops of back streets and junk boats make a nice change to the glorification of skyscrapers and luxury clubs in the heroic bloodshed films coming out of the island in the mid 80s, but the good points aren’t enough to pull this film above the rest of the crowd. To finish things off, the country-pop ending song “One up for the good guys” by Chip Taylor is awful.

Some criticisms of this film are based on this being a radical departure for Jackie, not in keeping with his usual knockabout roles and over-reliant on firearms rather than fisticuffs. It isn’t right to slam it based on this fact alone, but when judging this against other 80s cop movies it is thoroughly generic, with little helping it stand out from the crowd bar the few trademark Jackie Chan stunts and fights. Without those scenes, there is nothing to lift the Protector above its peers, such as Lethal Weapon or Beverly Hills Cop, so in all it is hard to recommend the film as either an entry into the Jackie canon or as a cop movie.

Film Review By: James Stafton

You can buy this DVD at: www.hongkong-store.com

theprotector.jpg

theprotector1.jpg

theprotector2.jpg

theprotector4.jpg



2 Comments

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Albert
Sep 25, 2008 14:53

The American version of this movie is exactly how it is described. The Hong Kong version, which Jackie reshot after a falling out with Glickenhaus, is much better. He crafted a more intricate film, including a subplot with Sally Yeh as a ballet dancer whom he falls for. Not to mention the fight scene between Chan and Wallace is done the real Chan way. This would become the prototype for Chan’s classic film Police Story. In essence, if there is a choice between the two version, Chan’s reshot HK version stands out as the victor.

ChanFan
Oct 19, 2008 8:41

The American version is fine, and there’s nothing wrong with Chan’s accent. He speaks very good English and if you have trouble understanding him you need to have your ears checked.
The ending song isn’t awful at all. Just because you’re not into that style doesn’t make it awful. It does fit the theme of the movie. When writing a review take the item for what it is and think intelligently instead of writing off with your clear bias. You put the review on this site and the hk site.

Leave a Reply

Comment

 

Most Popular Content

    Subscribe to Screen Power and Jade Screen magazine
    Hong Kong Store
    Jackie Chan Store
    Exclusive Events
    HK Stars
    Submit a review
    Jackie Chan Tea

Articles - Dec 23, 2008 3:23 - 9 Comments

Battle of Wits Comes To UK DVD & Blu-ray

More In Articles


Exclusive Events - Oct 15, 2008 7:51 - 13 Comments

2009 Hong Kong Movie London Screening

More In Exclusive Events


News - Jan 7, 2009 2:37 - 0 Comments

Bruce Lee’s Home To Become Major Tourist Attraction

More In News